Top 10 OXO Butter Keepers
for December 2022

MOOZ Themes editors select recommendations independently, so your purchase through our link may earn us a commission.

Looking for the best oxo kitchen tools? Our editors researched 10 of the top options to determine which one is the best. In this update, we purchased and tested 6 of the top oxo butter keepers. We evaluated them based on how easy they were to use, cleaning ability, and how well they held up to daily use. Our helpful comparison chart provides a side-by-side analysis of key characteristics, and we've included a list of our recommendations with the key features to consider when making your buying decision.

A butter keeper is a handy tool to keep butter fresh. These handy kitchen tools help you manage the butter you store in your fridge and prevent it from melting and getting crusty or hard. Whether you need to preserve butter in your fridge or use it in your baking, a butter keeper is a useful tool for every kitchen. We've tested the best butter keepers on the market, and we think you'll find the right one for your needs and budget.

1
9.7
SCORE
OXO Good Grips Prep and Go Condiment Keeper

OXO Good Grips Prep Go and Condiment Keeper

by OXO International Ltd.

Tucks easily into lunch or sports bags

OXO's Prep and Go Condiment Keeper is just about the best condiment jar you can buy. It is airtight, leak-proof, dishwasher safe, and unbelievably easy to clean. The Prep and Go Condiment Keeper holds one tablespoon of liquid, and it's even large enough to accommodate your favorite salad dressings. The lid is airtight, so liquids will never spill or leak, and even sauces and salad dressings don't leak if you shake it up. The Prep and Go Condiment Keeper is dishwasher-safe, so it's easy to clean, and it's made of dishwasher-safe plastic, so it's BPA-free and dishwasher-safe. The Prep and Go Condiment Keeper is small enough to throw in your backpack or purse, and it's small enough to fill with condiments and dressings to take to work or on a picnic. It's even small enough to fit in a drawer in the kitchen. The Prep and Go Condiment Keeper is a no-brainer.

2
9.7
SCORE
Butter Dish with Lid for Countertop - Butter Stick Container with Freshness Seal - Bamboo Lid Cutting and Chopping Board Butter Keeper - Kensington London Butter Crock for Counter Top - Gray - 23oz

KENSINGTON LONDON Butter Dish Lid with for Countertop

by Kensington London

Premium materials. Almost unbreakable galvanized iron body (unlike glass and ceramic dishes), with BPA-free, food-grade powder-coating. Hand-finished, environmentally-friendly bamboo wood cover.

The Kensington London Butter Dish with Lid for Countertop is an attractive storage option for butter or other spreads that takes up little counter space. The lid is removable and can be used as a chopping board, serving tray, or cheese board. The container itself is attractive enough to sit on a countertop or table, and makes it a breeze to keep butter fresh. The airtight lid keeps butter fresh, and means you won't be opening it every 5 minutes to stir, which helps keep the butter from becoming too soft. The lid has a slight curve, so it can be used as a serving tray as well, and the butter dish itself has a lip around the outside edge, so butter doesn't roll off. The container is made from bamboo, so it's light, sturdy, and naturally antimicrobial, making it an excellent option for spreads and other foods. The lid and bowl are dishwasher safe, but the lid is fairly delicate, so hand washing is recommended. Overall, the Kensington London Butter Dish with Lid for Countertop is an attractive, practical storage option for butter or other spreads that takes up little counter space.

3
9.1
SCORE
OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Butter Dish

OXO Good Grips Steel Stainless Butter Dish

by OXO

Dish designed to keep butter from slipping off tray and dirtying lid.BPA free

The OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Butter Dish is a simple, elegant, and practical butter dish. The stainless steel construction is durable enough for the kitchen, and it's elegant enough to use at the table. The stoppers on either side keep butter in place, and the lid rests on the dish without sliding off during transport. The clear lid makes it easy to see when the butter is empty, and it's removable for easy cleaning. The dish is small, so it's a good choice for smaller families, or for guests who only eat butter occasionally. The butter dish's small size also makes it a good choice for travel, as the small size makes it easy to pack, and the stoppers make it less likely to spill.

4
9
SCORE
Sweese 303.101 Large Butter Dish - Airtight Butter Keeper Holds Up to 2 Sticks of Butter - Porcelain Container with Beech Wooden Lid, White

Sweese 303.101 Large Butter Dish

by Sweese

NO MORE MESS THANKS TO THE DEEP DESIGN - The tall and deep design helps stop the butter sticking to the top of the lid and staying there when you pick up the lid. Without mess, this Sweese modern butter dish adds a touch of elegance to your kitchen.

The Sweese 303.101 Large Butter Dish is a high-quality butter dish that fits in well with modern kitchen decor. It's dishwasher-safe, so cleanup is a simple task, and the container itself is made of porcelain, which is both lightweight and easy to wipe clean. The lid is made of beech wood, which provides a nice contrast to the white container, and it's coated in silicone, which keeps the lid tightly sealed. The beech wood also ages gracefully, giving the butter dish a lived-in look. The lid is easy to open, but the ring seal keeps it closed. The lid snaps on and off easily, and it's wide enough to hold two sticks of butter. Overall, this is a great butter dish, and it's one of the best ones we've seen.

5
8.7
SCORE
Home Acre Designs Butter Dish with Lid for Countertop - Unbreakable Metal Container & Covered Mess-Free Butter Keeper - Large Vintage Farmhouse Style Dishes

Home Acre Designs Butter with Dish Lid for Countertop

by Home Acre Designs

Vintage Look: Farmhouse dishes and decor are all the rage, and this butter tray really delivers. From the sleek cursive to the simple design, you can feel the rustic farm vibes on this large butter dish!

The Home Acre Designs butter dish keeps butter fresh, and it's built to last. The butter storage dish has a deep design that keeps the butter from spreading out as it melts. The butter dish also keeps butter from sticking to the lid, so butter won't make a mess. The butter keeper is made from stainless steel, so it won't stain, chip, or dent. The butter dish is large enough to hold up 2 sticks of butter, so it's easy to store butter in the fridge or on the counter. The butter dish has a sturdy, thick handle, so it's easy to pour butter out of the dish. The butter dish has a deep frame, so the butter stays in the dish instead of spreading out. The butter dish has a bamboo lid with a cutting board attached to it. The lid can also be used as a cutting board, so the butter dish doubles as a butter cutter and a butter keeper. The butter dish has a nonskid base, so it won't slide around on your counter. The butter dish also has a nonskid base, so the butter dish won't tip over. The butter dish has a wooden lid, so the butter dish is sturdy and durable. The butter dish has a removable bamboo lid, so it's easy to clean and sanitize. The butter dish has a clear lid, so it's easy to check the butter level. The butter dish has a wooden lid, so the butter dish is easy to clean. The butter dish has a wooden lid, so the butter dish is easy to clean.

6
8.6
SCORE
OXO Good Grips Wide Butter & Cream Cheese Dish

OXO Good Grips Wide & Butter Cream Cheese Dish

by OXO

Clear lid rests on dish without sliding off during transport and is easy to remove

The OXO Good Grips Wide Butter & Cream Cheese Dish is a good choice for anyone who wants a butter dish that is not only attractive, but also easy to use and clean. The wide, shallow dish is big enough for two 8-ounce sticks of butter or 4 ounces of cream cheese, which fits in nicely with the 8-ounce capacity. The sides are raised slightly, which helps hold the butter in place while cutting it, and the dish has a non-slip bottom that keeps it from sliding around on countertops. The included lid fits neatly above the dish, so the butter stays fresh. The dish is dishwasher safe, and the lid is top-rack only. It also fits neatly into the dishwasher, so cleanup is quick and easy. The OXO Good Grips Wide Butter & Cream Cheese Dish is an attractive addition to any kitchen, and it's a good, sturdy choice for butter lovers.

7
8.6
SCORE
SWEEJAR Ceramics Butter Dish with Lid, Butter Keeper Container, East/West Coast Butter, 7 inches

SWEEJAR Ceramics Butter Dish with Lid

Unique Design - The top knob design is easier to open, and the butter plate cover has an elegant curved radius edge design. The thick wall design is designed to prevent the butter from becoming too hard in the refrigerator or to remain soft at room temperature.

The SWEEJAR Ceramics Butter Dish with Lid is a handsome, simple butter dish that complements a variety of kitchens and table styles. The butter dish is ceramic, making it dishwasher, microwave, oven, and refrigerator safe. The butter dish is shaped so that butter sticks can be inserted completely upright, with the butter sloping naturally across the dish. The large capacity holds enough butter for a whole stick, and it's ideal for butter sticks from East and West Coast butter. The butter dish is practical, too: it fits easily into most kitchen drawers, and the large opening makes it easier to grease the entire stick before inserting it into the dish. The butter dish is heavy enough to keep butter from melting, but it also has a large, unglazed opening at the bottom, so butter can escape if a dish is left on a warming setting. The butter dish is elegant, too: its simple white glaze and classic shape make it look as good as it performs. The butter dish is a handsome, practical accessory for any kitchen.

8
7.6
SCORE
OXO Good Grips Butter Dish

OXO Good Grips Butter Dish

by OXO

Dish designed to keep butter from slipping off tray and dirtying lid

OXO's Good Grips Butter Dish is a simple, well-priced butter dish that's designed to be sturdy and durable. It's made from durable, non-porous plastic, which makes it easy to clean, and it has a butter cup that rests inside without sliding off during transport. The lid is transparent, so it's easy to check the amount of butter left in your stick. The butter cup is tall and wide enough to accommodate all sizes of butter sticks, and it also has measurement markings on the side, which helps you determine how much butter you've used. The sides are also vented, so the butter can breathe, and there's a stopper on either side of it, which helps keep the butter in place while cutting it. The lid also sits on top of the butter cup without sliding off, so it's easy to remove. The butter dish is dishwasher-safe, and it's fairly light, so it's easy to take with you when cooking away from home.

9
7.6
SCORE
OXO Good Grips POP Container - Airtight Food Storage - 0.6 Qt for Tea and More

OXO Good Grips POP Container

by OXO

OXO Good Grips POP Containers airtight, space-efficient design keeps dry foods fresh and your cupboards organized

The OXO Good Grips POP Container is flexible and versatile, and it's ideal for storing small, irregularly shaped food, such as tea bags, coffee, grains and pasta. The lid is airtight, so you won't have to worry about any of your stored foods drying out, and the containers stack neatly and work great in the fridge or freezer. The container's 0.6-quart capacity isn't the largest, and it's a little smaller than some of the other picks on this list, but it's plenty for most small households. The container's handle is well-designed, but it's a little short, and it's made of hard plastic. The container also isn't microwave-safe, so you can't store liquid in it. The OXO Good Grips POP Container works well for tea bags, but we recommend stainless steel or glass tea containers for loose tea.

10
7.6
SCORE
Butter Dish with Lid For Countertop - Modern Bamboo Dark Grey Butter Crock - Dishwasher Safe Butter Keeper - Perfectly Sized Butter Holder Container For Large European Style Butter such as Kerrygold

Cooler Kitchen Butter Dish Lid with For Countertop

by Cooler Kitchen

EYE CATCHING MODERN DESIGN - Our unique, modern Scandinavian design is cool looking on any kitchen counter, and is a great gift for family or friends who will enjoy it in their kitchen for years to come.

The Butter Dish with Lid is well-constructed, and the lid fits securely. It's dishwasher-safe, but hand washing is recommended, because it scratches easily in the dishwasher. The dish is 11 inches tall and 6 inches in diameter, which is the perfect size for a European-style butter container. The lid is 4 inches tall and 4 inches in diameter, and it fits snugly on the dish. The dish contains ridges that create a tight seal so the butter doesn't leak, and the ridges also help the butter soften in the microwave. The dish is dark in color, so it's easy to find in the pantry, and the lid has a pretty bamboo pattern. The dish is a little smaller than our previous pick, the Le Creuset Stoneware Butter Dish, but the handle makes it easier to use, and the ridges make transferring the butter from the dish to the microwave easier. Our only complaint is that the ridges on the lid don't create a tight seal, so the butter leaks out when you transfer it to the microwave.

expand_less

I Agree
We use cookies to enhance and personalise your experience with us by collecting information about the pages you visit and actions taken on the site. More details